‘Vote Restore get Labour!’ Reform despair as they lose election by just two votes
Reform UK has suffered a painfully narrow electoral defeat after Labour snatched a council seat in Dudley by just two votes, triggering a fresh political argument over whether smaller parties are splitting support on the right.
Labour candidate Caroline Reid secured 874 votes in St James’s ward, narrowly defeating Reform UK’s Chris Chivers, who received 872. The difference between the two candidates was just 0.1 percentage points, turning what might otherwise have been an ordinary local by-election into a closely watched political contest.
The result represents a Labour gain from Reform and a dramatic reversal of the outcome in May 2026, when Nigel Farage’s party won the ward comfortably with 1,630 votes and a majority of 903 over Labour.
This time, Labour’s share of the vote increased by 16.2 percentage points to 38%, while Reform’s fell by 11 points to 37.9%.
The narrow margin has prompted questions about the impact of Restore Britain, the party led by Rupert Lowe, which received 159 votes. Some Reform supporters have suggested that those votes could have made the difference between victory and defeat.
The argument has been captured in comments circulating online, including the slogan: “Vote Restore get Labour!”
However, while the arithmetic makes the question difficult to ignore, there is no evidence establishing how Restore Britain’s supporters would have voted if the party had not contested the election.
The result has therefore created two separate political questions: why Reform lost a ward it had previously won comfortably, and whether the emergence of additional parties could make it more difficult for right-wing candidates to secure victories in closely contested constituencies.
Labour wins by just two votes
The final result in St James’s ward could hardly have been closer.
Caroline Reid finished with 874 votes, compared with 872 for Reform’s Chris Chivers. The Conservatives came third, with Sam Firmstone receiving 317 votes, equivalent to 13.8%.
Restore Britain’s Tristian Owens secured 159 votes, representing 6.9%, while Green Party candidate Katherine Alice Poole received 79 votes, or 3.4%.
The two-vote difference between Labour and Reform means that a very small number of ballots determined which party gained control of the seat.

Reform UK leader Nigel Farage (Image: Getty)
For Labour, the result represents an important local victory and an opportunity to demonstrate that Reform’s previous electoral success does not necessarily guarantee continued support.
For Reform, the outcome will be particularly frustrating because the party had previously established a substantial advantage in the ward.
In May 2026, Reform won St James’s with 1,630 votes and a majority of 903 over Labour. Just a few months later, the party has lost the same seat by the smallest possible margin in a closely fought contest.
The difference between the two elections illustrates how quickly local political circumstances can change.
However, the result should also be considered in the context of turnout, candidate selection and the issues affecting local residents. A by-election is not a direct national opinion poll, and its outcome cannot automatically be used to predict how voters would behave in a general election.
Even so, the scale of the reversal is likely to attract attention from both parties as they consider their strategies for future contests.
Restore Britain’s 159 votes spark political row
The most controversial aspect of the result has been the performance of Restore Britain.
Rupert Lowe’s party received 159 votes, significantly more than the two-vote margin separating Labour and Reform.
That has prompted some Reform supporters to argue that Restore Britain may have cost their party the seat by attracting voters who might otherwise have supported Chivers.
One social media commenter wrote: “Restore are a vote for Labour.”
Another argued that the party was taking votes away from Reform, while a further commenter suggested there had been “shrewd tactical voting on the Left”, pointing to the Green Party’s reduced vote share.
The argument is straightforward: if a proportion of Restore Britain’s supporters would otherwise have voted Reform, the party’s presence could have affected the final result.
But that is a hypothetical scenario, not an established fact.
There is no available evidence showing how those 159 voters would have behaved if Owens had not appeared on the ballot paper. Some might have supported Reform, others could have voted Conservative, Labour or Green, while some may have stayed at home.
The same uncertainty applies to the Conservative vote.
It would therefore be misleading to assume that all Restore Britain voters would automatically have transferred their support to Reform.
Nevertheless, the numerical relationship between the votes is striking. Restore Britain received more than 75 times the number of votes separating the two leading candidates.
That comparison explains why the result has become a talking point among supporters of the right-wing parties.
It also highlights a wider challenge for parties competing for voters with similar political priorities: multiple candidates can appeal to overlapping sections of the electorate, but their supporters do not necessarily share identical preferences.
Why the result has reignited the right-wing vote-splitting debate
The argument surrounding St James’s reflects a recurring issue in British politics.
When several parties compete for voters who share some political positions, their combined support may be greater than the support received by the leading candidate. Under a first-past-the-post electoral system, however, votes are counted separately for each candidate.

Restore Britain leader Rupert Lowe MP (Image: Getty)
This means that a candidate can win even when other parties collectively attract a substantial number of voters with broadly similar political preferences.
The system does not redistribute votes automatically between parties.
A voter who chooses Restore Britain does not have their ballot transferred to Reform if their preferred candidate loses. The same applies to Conservative, Green and other candidates.
This creates an incentive for parties to consider whether standing candidates in particular areas could affect the chances of another party with overlapping support.
However, there is a significant difference between sharing some political positions and representing identical voters.
Supporters of Reform, the Conservatives and Restore Britain may disagree on leadership, policies, economic priorities, immigration, public services and the direction of the country.
Some may see one party as a more credible alternative than another, even if they broadly agree on certain issues.
For that reason, it is not possible to treat the combined vote of right-wing parties as though it belongs to a single political movement.
The Dudley result may nevertheless encourage discussions about tactical voting, electoral cooperation and whether smaller parties should prioritise their own representation or consider the broader consequences of standing candidates in closely contested wards.
Reform’s previous victory makes the defeat more significant
The result is particularly uncomfortable for Reform because of the party’s strong performance in the previous election.
In May 2026, Reform secured 1,630 votes and defeated Labour by a majority of 903.
That result suggested the party had successfully established itself as the leading political force in the ward at that time.
The latest contest has produced a very different outcome.
Reform’s vote share fell by 11 percentage points to 37.9%, while Labour’s increased by 16.2 points to 38%.
These changes indicate that the two parties entered the by-election with considerably different levels of support compared with the previous contest.
However, interpreting the movement requires caution. The number of people voting, the circumstances surrounding the by-election and the candidates involved can all influence the result.
It would be wrong to conclude from one ward that Reform’s national support has collapsed or that Labour has recovered its position across the country.
Nevertheless, the result provides an important local example of how Reform can lose territory it previously won by a substantial margin.
For Farage, the immediate political problem is that the party has failed to retain a seat it gained only months earlier.
The defeat may also prompt questions about whether Reform’s campaign organisation can maintain its momentum in areas where it has previously enjoyed a strong result.
Conservatives finish third as smaller parties influence the contest
The Conservatives received 317 votes, finishing behind both Labour and Reform.
Sam Firmstone’s result represented 13.8% of the vote, placing the party a considerable distance from the two leading candidates.
The Conservative performance is relevant to the wider discussion because the party is also competing for voters who may be attracted to Reform or Restore Britain.
The presence of three parties seeking support from parts of the same electorate creates a more complicated electoral landscape.
However, it would be inaccurate to assume that Conservative voters would necessarily have supported Reform in the absence of the Conservative candidate.
Some may have chosen Labour, Restore Britain or another party. Others may not have voted at all.
The Green Party received 79 votes, or 3.4%, with Katherine Alice Poole finishing fifth.
The relatively small Green vote has also been mentioned in online discussions about tactical voting. One commenter suggested that left-wing voters may have coordinated their support more effectively.
Again, the available figures do not establish whether any organised tactical voting took place.
A low or reduced vote share for one party does not, on its own, prove that its former supporters deliberately moved to another candidate to prevent a different party from winning.
Understanding those decisions would require more detailed evidence, such as voter surveys or interviews with people who participated in the election.
Turnout highlights the limits of the result
Turnout in the St James’s by-election was 22.45%, according to Dudley Council.
This means that fewer than one-quarter of eligible voters participated in the contest.
Low turnout is common in some local by-elections, particularly when compared with national elections, but it can have a substantial influence on the final distribution of votes.
A relatively small number of additional voters can change the outcome when the leading candidates are separated by only two ballots.
It also means the result reflects the choices of those who participated rather than the views of every resident in the ward.
Some residents may have been unaware of the contest, while others may have decided that none of the candidates represented their priorities.
For political parties, the challenge is therefore not simply to persuade existing supporters to remain loyal. They must also find ways to encourage people who do not normally vote in local elections to participate.
The two-vote margin makes that challenge particularly visible.
Had just a few additional voters chosen differently, the result could have changed. But the official outcome remains clear: Labour won the seat with 874 votes.
By-election triggered by Reform councillor’s resignation
The contest was called after Reform councillor Ivor Robinson resigned for personal reasons relating to his health.
Robinson had won St James’s ward for Reform in May 2026, when the party overturned Labour’s previous control.
His departure created the vacancy that led to the latest by-election.
The circumstances are important because the contest was not originally triggered by a scheduled election or a wider change in the political control of the council.
Instead, it provided an opportunity for voters to decide who should replace the departing councillor.
The result means Labour has regained the seat after only a few months of Reform representation.
For Caroline Reid, the immediate responsibility will be to represent residents and address local concerns. The narrowness of her victory means that she enters the role with a result that demonstrates just how closely divided the contest was.
For Chris Chivers and Reform, the outcome will be a disappointment, particularly given the party’s previous majority.
The next challenge for both parties will be to establish whether the result reflects a lasting change in local support or circumstances specific to this by-election.
Rupert Lowe’s party faces questions over its electoral role
Restore Britain’s performance has placed Rupert Lowe’s party at the centre of a debate that could become increasingly relevant as more parties compete for similar voters.
Receiving 159 votes may not have been enough to secure the seat, but it was sufficient to become a major talking point after the result.
The party now faces a familiar challenge for smaller political movements: how to build an independent electoral presence without becoming defined by the effect its candidates have on the fortunes of larger parties.
If Restore Britain continues to contest seats where Reform and the Conservatives are competitive, its candidates may influence the final distribution of votes.
But that does not necessarily mean the party should withdraw or that its supporters would accept instructions to vote for another organisation.
Political parties exist to represent their own supporters and advance their own programmes. Their ability to stand candidates is an important part of the democratic process.
The question for Restore Britain is whether it can turn its vote share into a more established political presence.
For Reform, the challenge is different. It must convince voters who may be attracted to smaller parties that supporting its candidates offers the representation they want.
A two-vote defeat with consequences beyond Dudley
The St James’s result is a reminder of how unforgiving first-past-the-post elections can be.
Labour’s Caroline Reid won with 874 votes, while Reform’s Chris Chivers received 872. A difference of just two ballots was enough to determine which party gained the seat.
The 159 votes received by Restore Britain have made the outcome particularly controversial, but they do not prove that the party cost Reform the victory.
That distinction is essential when interpreting the result.
The by-election has undoubtedly reignited questions about political fragmentation, tactical voting and competition between parties seeking similar voters.
For Labour, it represents a narrow but valuable gain. For Reform, it is a frustrating defeat in a ward where it previously enjoyed a substantial majority. For Restore Britain, it provides evidence of a measurable electoral presence, while also exposing the scrutiny that smaller parties can face when their votes may affect a closely fought contest.
The wider political significance will depend on what happens in future elections.
If Reform continues to lose support in areas where smaller parties are also competing, the question of electoral cooperation may become more prominent. If Labour can repeat its Dudley performance elsewhere, the result could form part of a broader recovery.
For now, however, one fact dominates the story: Labour has regained St James’s ward by just two votes, leaving Reform to confront an electoral defeat that will be debated long after the count was declared.
